It is not accurate to say that academia is refusing to debate the validity of special relativity. In fact, scientific theories, including special relativity, are subject to continuous scrutiny, critical analysis, and debate within the scientific community. Scientific progress relies on questioning and challenging existing theories, including those that are well-established.
However, it is important to note that special relativity is a highly successful and extensively tested theory that has withstood numerous experimental validations over the past century. It has made predictions that have been confirmed to an extraordinary degree of accuracy in a wide range of experiments, including those involving high-energy particle physics, atomic clocks, GPS systems, and cosmological observations.
When scientific theories have been extensively tested and validated, they are generally accepted as the best descriptions of natural phenomena based on the available evidence. While debates and discussions about the theoretical foundations, interpretations, or potential limitations of a theory are always ongoing, the overwhelming empirical support for special relativity has led to its widespread acceptance among the scientific community.
That being said, if someone has specific issues or concerns regarding special relativity or any scientific theory, they are welcome to engage in scholarly discussions, publish their research findings, and present their arguments within the scientific community. Science progresses through the critical evaluation of ideas and evidence-based discussions.
It is worth mentioning that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. If someone proposes an alternative theory or challenges the established understanding, they need to provide rigorous and compelling evidence that explains the observed phenomena better than the existing theory. The burden of proof lies on those proposing alternative ideas to demonstrate their validity through experimentation, observation, and peer-reviewed research.
Overall, academia fosters an environment where scientific theories and ideas are constantly evaluated, and debates are an integral part of scientific progress. However, for a well-established theory like special relativity, the consensus among experts is based on extensive empirical evidence, making it a highly reliable framework for understanding the behavior of space, time, and motion.